Caramel Chocolate Brownie Crinkle Cookies Recipe (2024)

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

1. Dorothy @ Crazy for Crust says:

   Oh my goodness! These look amazing. Brownies and caramel are two of my addictions right now. :) I'd love for you to share these on Crazy Sweet Tuesday!

2. melody-mae says:

   OH MY WORD! My mouth is watering and tummy is growling! :)

3. Christa says:

   I love this!! Can't wait to make 'em. Thanks!

4. elise says:

   Oh my goodness this sounds so delightful!

5. Danielle says:

   I love brownies -they are my all time favorite dessert and you stuffed them with caramels?! Bookmarking.

6. Lindsay says:

   What?? I have made chocolate crinkle cookies, but adding caramel & brownie--I must try! Thanks for sharing this!

7. Jocelyn says:

   ooohhh baby!!! Those look GREAT!!! You guys always have the best stuff on your blog...love it!

8. Vicki Bensinger says:

   These look amazing. Chocolate and caramel and they're semi-homemade. Perfect for a hurried day and it doesn't look like you sacrifice taste either. I just printed this recipe. I hope you'll add it to my Virtual Cookie Swap that I'm having online right now. Plus I have a great giveaway to go with it. Please add these to my cookie swap. I know they'll be a huge hit. Enter your recipe here:
   http://in-homeculinaryclasses.blogspot.com/2011/10/virtual-cookie-swap-giveaway.html

9. cheapcraftymama says:

   Oh wow those look so delish! I think I'll make them tonight!

10. Tanya says:

    I have yet to make cookies with caramel in them. This is pinned to bake soon.

11. Danielle says:

    I wanted to let you know that I featured this fabulous recipe on my "What I Bookmarked This Week" post today. Stop by and see!

12. craftedniche says:

    This recipe is NOT going to help my diet!

13. Kathryn says:

    I make caramel chocolate cookies an even easier way and they are just as good, probably better! I use devil's food cake mix and rolos. I make the cake batter (mix, 1/3 cup vegetable oil, 2 eggs) and I make a ball of cake batter. I put the candy in them and bake 7 minutes!! they taste DIVINE and everyone loves them! they are so easy and quick to make too

14. Anonymous says:

    These were really difficult to make, maybe I was doing something wrong? The batter is gooey and impossible to form around the caramel. More flour? I made the apple cider caramel cookies, without a problem.

15. Moore or Less Cooking says:

    This looks like a winner for Christmas cookies! Can't wait to make them!

    Nettie

16. Tenille says:

    Yummy. These look divine. Thanks for sharing. I would love it if you could link this up to our linky party going on right now.

    http://www.junkintheirtrunk.blogspot.com/2011/11/link-it-up-wednesday-5.html

    See Also

    Barbecue Smoky Sweet Rub Recipe - Kid Friendly Things To Do

17. {amy k.} says:

    i'm definitely "pinning" this one, looks so yummy!

18. Anonymous says:

    I also had some severe problems when making these. The dough was way too gooey to roll around the caramels or form in any kind of a ball. I did add more flour, which I think ultimately screwed up the flavor and consistancy of the cookie. I also tried chilling the dough, but that didn't offer any improvements, either. I'm guessing I did something wrong, though I think I follwed the recipe exactly? I have tried several other recipes from this blog, all of which have been divine, so I'm not sure what the deal was?

19. Camille says:

    @ Anonymous- I am so sorry that they didn't work for both of you! I have no idea why? The only thing that I can figure is maybe the humidity? I know that's random, but I live in Utah where the air is super dry and my sister that lives in Missouri has to adapt some of our recipes because the air is so humid there- things just don't turn out the same for her! As far as adapting this recipe, I think that adding flour might ruin the flavor (like you said). I am not sure how to make it work! I am so sorry. Sometimes when the dough is sticky, I spray my hands with non-stick cooking spray and that seems to help me so that I can roll them into a ball. Once again, I am so sorry!

20. Anonymous says:

    My dough, when made according to the recipe, was way too gooey. Maybe something to do with the size of the brownie mix? Mine was 19.5 ounces, and said it was for a 9x13" pan, but some are different. I opened another box of brownie mix (I have a stash in my pantry......hahaha) and added about half-ish to the "dough" and they turned out perfect =)

21. Anonymous says:

    I also had the same problem with the dough being too wet. I ended up adding cocoa powder, hot chocolate mix, and shaved a bunch of chocolate into the mix. It thickened up and by adding some powdered sugar to my hands, was easy to form into balls. Once I baked it though, it was 50/50 on if the caramel would melt through the bottom. All in all, don't think I'll make these again.

22. Cindi says:

    These are as good as they look! Thank you for the recipe.

23. Shari Brooks says:

    i make this cookie at home (without caramels) except it's called Earthquake Cookies. I don't use a mix and it's just as easy. I use cocoa and keep the batter in over night. I roll them out the next day in confectioner's sugar and then bake them. This makes the cookies rise very high and then crack! check it out: http://www.myjudythefoodie.com/2011/6/earhtquake-cookies-they'll-make-you-tremble/

24. Julie says:

    Yummy! I was worried about the consistency being too runny because of previous comments (and I live in the midwest so I was worried about the humidity) so I added the water and oil in a little at a time. I ended up leaving half the oil out and put them in the fridge before rolling. They turned out perfect! i probably still could have added the rest of the oil, but I figured it was probably healthier without it, and I like a thicker dough :)

25. Unknown says:

    wish I had read the previous comments before making these - ditto on the runny. Added the cocoa powder, but cookies still didn't turn out edible at all.

26. Michelle says:

    These sounded delicious, but I had the same problem with the dough being more like batter. I live in Utah so it was not the humidity. I added flour to thicken it up which worked but made the texture blah. Maybe I will try again now that I have read the comments and use the extra brownie mix.

27. Unknown says:

    I just tried this recipe and had the problem with the batter being too runny. I added more flour until it got to a consistency with which I could work with some and the sprayed my hands with Pam cooking spray so it wouldn't stick. I was able to form it around the caramel but I found when I transfered them to a cooling rack, my caramel fell out. I tried one anyway just to see if the taste was compromised and I think they still tasted really good, not a strong flour taste. I've currently got a batch cooling on the pan to see if that helps with my caramel problem. Anyone else have that problem or did I do something wrong?

28. Andrea Seyfried Pruitt says:

    I had the same issues with these as most of the previous people stated with runny dough, it was more like brownie batter and not dough. I doubled the recipe so I would be able to take 6 dozen cookies to an exchange party. I thought maybe doubling it made it worse. So I followed one previous comment and added almost another whole box of brownie mix. this worked. I had to bake mine for about 12 minutes to get them to set up enough, but they taste amazing! Adding more brownie mix, or less oil and water seem to be working with this recipe the best! Have fun experimenting and indulging!

29. Six Sisters says:

    We are so sorry this has been such a bad experience for you. We didnt' have any problems. But you are not alone after reading the comments. Maybe try adding less water.

30. rhiannon watterson says:

    i added little less than 1/2 cup of extra flour. I also rubbed powdered sugar on my hands to help the dough not stick to them. They still were amazing. I also drizzled caramel ontop of them from the left over caramels.

31. rhiannon watterson says:

    These were a huge hit at my cookie exchange party. I am making them again tonight for my office christmas party for tomorrow. we are also exchanging cookies.

    thanks! will definitely add these to my recipe book.

32. Zazeezoo says:

    I put in only half of the oil after reading everyone's comments about it being too runny and these turned out absolutely FABULOUS! <3

33. Six Sisters says:

    So glad to know! Hopefully everyone will see your comment! Thanks for letting us know. -The Six Sisters

34. Jeff Guernsey says:

    Perhaps the brand of brownies makes a difference. What kind of brownie mix did you use?

35. Six Sisters says:

    We used Betty Crocker. Some of the comments above used less water or less oil. I hope they work out for you! -The Six Sisters

36. Morgan Swenson says:

    I made these tonight and they turned out perfect!! I did what some other people suggested and just added my water and oil a little bit at a time til I had the perfect consistency. This recipe is definitely going in my recipe box :).

37. Beth Wagoner says:

    I also tried in vain to make these cookies. I wanted to take them to a cookie exchange at work tomorrow. The batter was more like cake batter, so I added flour and cocoa til I could attempt to work with it. Unfortunately, the cookie part tasted dry after baking, and the caramel got hard and impossible to chew after cooling. I threw the batch away. I think the recipe had way too much water in it. Perhaps a little more oil and way less water would work. And by the way, I am in Iowa ..and in mid-December my house is extremely dry, so it isn't a humidity variance. Very disappointing.

38. Janelle says:

    Thank goodness I read the other comments before I gave up and pitched the cookie mixture. It was VERY gooey. I should have added the oil/water/egg mixture a little at a time to get the right consistency but since I failed to read other comments prior to mixing the batter, I resorted to adding more brownie mix. I added just enough extra brownie mixture until it was no longer gooey. I live in the midwest and it is winter, so very dry. Used the correct size brownie mix. I now have a half used brownie mix that I guess I will save for the next batch of these cookies ;)

39. Stephanie H says:

    SO wished I read the comments before attempting...didn't work for me at all...

40. Susan says:

    I have been making these cookies for years now. I LOVE this recipe. I have found that only Pilsbury brownie mix has enough bulk to make this dough without it being runny. It's the only brand I use and the recipe is always perfect. My other adaptation is using Rolos instead of caramels. You still get the caramel kick but it's wrapped in gooey chocolate and the cookies never really harden. I make these every Christmas and the kiddos love them. Warning, these are incredibly addictive!

41. Cyd says:

    Mmmmmm! Thanks Susan! Sounds delicious! Thanks so much for stopping by our blog!

42. Pamela says:

    I'm glad I'm not the only one questioning the consistency, I decided to put the in a mini muffin pan and place the caramel low chocolate in the center, down 2/3rds of the way so the dough bakes around it.